Reviews

Based on 1942 reviews
94%
(1835)
3%
(65)
1%
(13)
0%
(5)
1%
(24)
Delicious and super value - What more can you ask?

Simply a satisfied customer getting his value and delicious oysters. Can't ask for anything better. We will be back for more!

Fast deliveries and awesome taste.

Top notch oysters EVERY time

This is probably our 10th time ordering from these guys. They never disappoint and we have never gotten a bad oyster. If your wondering just order!

Loved them, great way to make friends.wish I could buy fifty.

W
Blackberry® Oysters
William Connelly
Great Service

Ordered 200 oysters. Arrived on time and had a great party. Everyone enjoyed. Will definitely do this again,

Yummy

Great Oysters for a fare shipped price!!!
Will be ordering more for sure…!

Super fresh oysters!

Loved shucking the oysters, they were easy to open and so fresh. Nice sized oysters and well flavored. Excellent!! Will be ordering again!

Arrived on time

Fresh oysters were a great addition to our fantasy draft party. There wasn't a bad one in the batch.

Yum

Loved tasting all four varieties. Very good.

Summer barbecue

Great for Barbecue and eating raw.

100 ct Farm Fresh Oyster Sampler + Shucking Knife

New mexico oysters

Fresh delicious oyster in new mexico. Always make it here fresh and alive even in 100 degree temperatures.

Fantastic customer support

We were so thankful for the customer support we received. You helped us every step of the way.

Celebrated an anniversary weekend with my girlfriend. We decided to look around for where we could order oysters to indulge in all weekend.

Wicomico not only had the best price, it had variety, it got here quickly and when they said it would, we got a variety of 4 oysters instead of just one kind, and they were EXTREMELY fresh. Even in the AZ Phoenix 110F heat.

I think there was maybe, 3 TOPS oysters that by the second day of eating them we didn't feel were worth risking eating. Incredible.

I've since recommended this company to many friends and family, and I will CERTAINTLY be ordering from them many times in the future

H
Rock Hole Oysters
Helen Muth
Great oysters and arrived in wonderful condition

This is the third time I have had Wicomico oysters and they are some of the best I have had. Well worth the shucking time. I had raw oysters as well as made oyster chowder when our fridge froze some of the oysters..

Great oysters. Will order again!

Delicious oysters delivered to your house

Oysters were delicious. We were very happy with our order and quick delivery. The shucking knife was a nice addition but not the best. We did have issues opening the Smith Point as probably 10 out of 25 shattered on us. Not sure if that was a problem with the oysters or the shuckers.

A
Peachtree Oysters
ARTURO Gervacio

Peachtree Oysters

Phenomenal oysters

Cold, fresh, great oysters overall

A
Smith Point Oysters
Andrew Dodds
Absolutely some of the best oysters I’ve ever had

Arrived on time, oysters were right at 38F and very well packaged. No fish smell at all, only that briny, fresh smell. I opted to try a few upon arrival and they were so fresh, great flavor and ample size. I will never go the local “fresh” market for oysters, I’m a customer for life.

Super tasty! Excellent.

Oysters arrived on time and in tact. So far the Blackberrys and Rock Hole are my favorite from a taste perspective. The Smithpoints are the hardest to open but nice and juicy. The Peachtrees actually becoming more of my favorite as they are super easy to open, and super tasty as well. All in all; not as salty as we have here on Long Island, due to river vs bay/ocean, …but very good quality oysters. Luvin em!

Delightful treat

Packing kept the sampler well protected. The oysters were well maintained and cleaned. Secondary prep and cleaning was minimal. Peach tree oysters were very well balanced with hints of fruit. Black berry oysters were buttery and sweet. Rock hole oysters were delightful. Truly enjoyed

Freshest and tastiest oysters you will ever have

Awesome oysters

Extremely happy

A
Blackberry® Oysters
Astrid Hanover
Great oyster!

These oyster were perfect! Tasted great